MyBB Internal: One or more warnings occurred. Please contact your administrator for assistance.
MyBB Internal: One or more warnings occurred. Please contact your administrator for assistance.
MyBB Internal: One or more warnings occurred. Please contact your administrator for assistance.
MyBB Internal: One or more warnings occurred. Please contact your administrator for assistance.
Nightingale Forums - Nightingale Logo

Nightingale Forums

Full Version: Nightingale Logo
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2
We need a Logo!

Please vote on the following submissions:
Entries 1 to 6: [attachment=1]
Entries 7 to 12: [attachment=2]
Entries 13 to 18: [attachment=3]
Entry 19: [attachment=4]
Entry 20: [attachment=5]
Entry 21: [attachment=6]
Entry 22: [attachment=7]
Entry 23: [attachment=8]
Entry 24: [attachment=9]
Entry 25: [attachment=10]

Please note that these are "ideas" and not finished designed so comments are welcome.
8, 9 and 11 are my favorites. And I suppose that they all have similar ideas.
Also, 21 looks like a good SVG implementation of the above.
I would prefer 23 if the bird lost a bit of weight.
I think number 8 is the best that fits under all the places it may be used, icon for the application, weblogo and so on.

But the best idea at all may be some of the other on the same imagefile, like 9, 10, 11, 12. Maybe 13 would be nice to.

19 and 12 is also very good.
I like 19 the best. Plus it would pretty easy to manipulate too because of its simplicity.
Overall i like #22 the best. But i think a few of the others have potential. #11 would be cool if the moon like #22

I think logo vs icon should be a bit different anyway. Some of these work better for icons while others more towards logos
#19, #21 and #22 are good logos, but to my mind #5 is the best.

Some logos should be avoided because they can make people think to other players or softwares :
#13 (Amarok)
#3, #14 and #16 (iTunes)
Actually, it's a hard decision. The best choice depends on if we are going for cool, cute or classy... I think #5 is definitely the coolest one. But I think that #8 would be more appealing to the general population.
As with a lot of people, I'm torn between some of the logos... My favourites are definately 9, 19, and 22. But, it leads me to the question: How are we planning on using the logo? Will it be on a splash-screen, or worked into the player itself? I think 22 would be excellent as a splash screen, but a little too "rich" to integrate into the player itself. 19 would work in both places, and should be simple enough to work into an icon as well (I think it's always a good idea to match the icon with the logo, to prevent confusion). As for number 9... I like the styling, and it probably represents the most about what Nightingale is out of all three of the ones I mentioned, but the fact that it's on paper doesn't give it the same "oomph" as the other ones. Still, it's got huge potential were it redone in a graphics program.

Having said that: I remember one of the concerns about the logo on the last forum was the lack of a "community" element to the image... I'd like to propose an alteration to #19: Perhaps having three birds, sort of squished side by side and singing along, would give it a very Barbershop Trio look. I think the styling is punchy and modern, as well as being simple, and having the extra birds and a couple music notes would tie in both the community and music aspect. For some reason, the image that keeps popping into my head is that of three cartoon crows perched on a telephone wire, singing along... I think it's from a Disney movie, but I can't place it.
I like the idea of adding 2 more birds to #19. +1
Pages: 1 2